Should I Drink That was created in March of 2006 when Brad and Father Spoon realized a need for a craft beer review show that was aimed at educating and entertaining the everyday axis of evil (Coors, Bud, Miller) beer drinker and to show by example that you don’t have to be a stuck up snob to appreciate the finer qualities of craft beer.

The number one rule for the show is that no alcohol is EVER wasted. They hold true to their belief “Even if it’s crap, we drink it so you don’t have to!”. If they don’t like it, they chug it.

Brief History
The first show was released on May 5, 2006 (Cinco de Mayo) and has since grown a legion of fans world wide. As word of the show spreads, the SIDT guys have been featured on Pittsburgh Magazine, G4 Tech TV, Go Magazine, DRAFT Magazine, Zymurgy, Beaver County Times, WDVE, speakers at Podcamp Pittsburgh and penned a quarterly craft beer article for Flavor magazine and In September of 2009 SIDT passed the monumental 500,000 download mark,  broke 1,000,000 in December 2010 and passed 2,000,000 in 2012.

Known throughout many media circles as “Pittsburgh’s bad boys of craft beer”, Should I Drink That will remain committed to bring to you an informative and entertaining review of craft beer. We are your craft beer show!

One thing we enjoy doing is interacting with our fans. We are available on various social media sites so feel free to add us as friends and join our growing communities!

twitter   Instagram

Your host
Fr. Spoon Father Spoon hails from the port city of Erie in the Great Lakes region of Pennsylvania. Multimedia specialist by trade and connoisseur of craft beer by passion, spoon brings to the show a reformed Rolling Rock drinker’s point of view along with humor from his catholic upbringing which can only be told while wearing the appropriate collar. Spoon is a retired craft beer writer for and has contributed to various craft beer related publications. Follow his craft beer habits on Untappd
Favorite style of beer: Belgian Tripel
Brad Brad is a native of Butler PA and the guy that barstool legends are made from. There isn’t a craft beer that he’ll pass up, especially if you’re buying, and stunt that he can’t resist. He has a long career as a network engineer by day and homebrewer by night. After 8 seasons behind the mic, he has decided to see what life is like as a retired beercaster. Spoon paid tribute to his bestest beer buddy in EP 103.


In the News
“The 3 Rivers Artsfest with WPXI Helo Pilot”
(YaJagoff Podcast – June 2017)
The North Side Tour
(YaJagoff Podcast – May 2017)
Session 57 Part 1 – Bocktown Turns 10
(Over a Couple of Beers – December 2016)
Session 57 Part 2 – Bocktown Turns 10
(Over a Couple of Beers – December 2016)
A Party on the City Porte-Cochère
(YaJagoff Podcast – November 2016)
The First Porch Tour Rick Sebak and BBQ
(YaJagoff Podcast – July 2016)
Dormont man fires up barbecue website

(Pittsburgh Post Gazette – June 2016)
Episode of Disjointed Thoughts
(YaJagoff Podcast – April 2016)
Best Breweries in Pittsburgh
(Thrillist – May 2015)
Meet the MASH – “Should I Drink That?”

(Brooklyn Brewery Tumblr – June 2014)
Yakkin’ With Ya Jagoff

( – October 2013)
Learn to Homebrew Day
(Zymurgy – September/October 2013)
Surviving a New Year’s hangover
(Beaver Co. Times – December 2012)
Learn to Homebrew Day
(Zymurgy – September/October 2012)
Brewmasters quenching Pittsburghers’ demand for local ales

(Pittsburgh Tribune Review – March 2012)
All Saints spreads its beer across W.Pa.
(Pittsburgh Tribune Review – March 2012)
PittGirl Discovers Craft Beertopia
(Pittsburgh Magazine – August 2011)
East End Brewing gets Super boost from fans on Facebook

(Beaver Co. Times – January 2011)
Beer Hear!

(Pittsburgh Magazine – March 2010)
Links Worth a Look

(I Heart Pgh – February 2010)
Wrestling Mayhem Show & Should I Drink That “Grassroots Podcasting”
(Podcamp Pittsburgh – October 2009)
“The best Podcast you have never heard of is… Should I Drink That?”
(The Plastic Gear – July 2009)
“Should I Drink That” to host Beer School
(Pittsburgh Cultural Trust – 2009)
Links Worth a Look
(I Heart Pgh – December 2008)
PCPGH3 highlights new opportunities for branding a region
(Keystone Edge – October 2008)
Cooks and Consultants, Wrestlers and Writers…
(Podcamp Pittsburgh PR – October 2008)
Links Worth a Look
(I Heart Pgh – September 2008)
Father Spoon and sickpuppy
(The Ledger – August 2008)
Should I Drink That? They’ll tell you
(Beaver Co. Times – July 2008)
The Craft of Chugging

(Draft Magazine – July/August 2008)
Erie Native Brews Up Fun In His Hometown
( Global Erie – July 2008)
Is your craft beer in jeopardy?
(Flavor Magazine – Spring 2008)
Cold Hearted Love
(I Heart PGH – February 2008)
Bringing Iron City back to glory days
(Beaver Co. Times – October 2007)
Who knew beer and podcasts go together?
(Go Magazine – October 2007)
Internet Superstars to Attend PodCamp Pittsburgh 2

(Podcamp Pittsburgh PR – August 2007)
Worldwide Phenomenon PodCamp Returns to Pittsburgh

(Podcamp Pittsburgh PR – June 2007)

Contact SIDT!

[contact-form-7 404 "Not Found"]

Mailing Address

Should I Drink That?
PO Box 24517
Pittsburgh, PA 15234